Are you on the hunt for some thrilling true crime shows that’ll have you on the edge of your seat, finally escaping the endless sea of romance and so-called scary movies? Well, look no further because we’ve curated a selection of the absolute best true crime shows on Disney Plus. These shows are packed with tension, tragedy, and, best of all, they always put the bad guys behind bars by the end of it all.
Not only do these shows have gripping storylines, but they also feature some top-notch actors who absolutely crushed their roles. All you have to do is comfortably nestled in your favorite chair, your go-to snack within arm’s reach, and a Disney+ binge-watch marathon ahead of you.
So, sit back, relax, and prepare for an adrenaline-pumping, mind-boggling adventure as we reveal what to watch on Disney+.
Don’t forget to explore our recommendations for the best sci-fi movies and the best Hindi movies available on Disney+!
Under The Banner Of Heaven (2023)
 | Under The Banner Of Heaven | |
| Genre True Crime, Thriller | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Dustin Lance Black | 7.5/10 | |
| Cast Andrew Garfield, Sam Worthington, Daisy Edgar-Jones, Denise Gough, Wyatt Russell | ||
Under The Banner Of Heaven features the stellar talents of Andrew Garfield and Daisy Edgar Jones. Adapted from Jon Krakauer’s 2003 book of the same name, this series shadows Detective Pyre as he delves into the chilling real-life double murder of Brenda Lafferty and her 15-month-old daughter. While the investigation peels back layers, it exposes a dangerous group of fundamentalists who twist Mormon scripture to justify their heinous acts. In the process, Pyre finds himself confronting the darker chapters of his Church’s history and gradually losing his faith. Critics have showered the show with praise, labeling it a “profound” exploration of faith.
Wild Crime (2021)
 | Wild Crime | |
| Genre True Crime, Thriller | Seasons 2 | |
| Director Lisa Quijano Wolfinger | 7.3/10 | |
| Cast Linda Hayes, Lynn Kessler, Conor McCarthy, Pamela Mason Wagner | ||
Wild Crime the specially trained group of special agents that are in charge of looking into crimes that happen in Only 33 special agents countrywide are tasked with looking into crimes that take place on the 85 million acres that make up the National Park System. The documentary series follows a specially trained squad conducting investigations in America’s wildest and most inaccessible regions, tackling a new case each season.
Keeper of the Ashes: The Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders (2022)
![true crime on disney plus](https://screenbeasts.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Keeper-of-the-Ashes.webp") | Keeper of the Ashes: The Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders | |
| Genre True Crime, Mystery | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Remy Weber | 5.2/10 | |
| Cast Kristin Chenoweth, Sheri Farmer, Mike Reed | ||
Kristin Chenoweth, a celebrated performer, and actress, goes back to her roots to look into some of Oklahoma’s most notorious killings. In the true account Keeper of the Ashes, three young Oklahoma girls were discovered dead after spending their first night at a sleep-away camp. In the summer of 1977, the tragedy enthralled the country, as did the manhunt for and trial of their alleged killer. But decades later, questions surrounding the case are still a source of anxiety for the people of Tulsa, the local police, and the relatives of the victims.
City of Angels, City of Death (2021)
 | City of Angels, City of Death | |
| Genre True Crime | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Star Price | 7.8/10 | |
| Cast Matt Murphy, Edwin Modlin II, Bob Grogan | ||
The Hillside Strangler, who murdered at least 12 young women in the Hollywood Hills and San Fernando Valley, is featured in the first episode of the series. Bob Grogan and Tom Lange, the investigators who looked into the case, knew right once that they were dealing with a crafty and systematic murderer. The Hillside Strangler was probably working with a partner, which made the investigation more difficult. While the Hillside Strangler case was being investigated, the Skid Row Stabber was frightening the streets of Los Angeles. This murderer targeted the destitute and frequently stabbed them to death in back alleys and abandoned structures.
Have You Seen This Man? (2022)
 | Have You Seen This Man? | |
| Genre True Crime, Mystery | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Sunny Hostin | 7.8/10 | |
| Cast Harvey Roberts, Zach Meiser, Jarred Harper | ||
The 2022 American real crime documentary miniseries, Have You Seen This Man?, was produced by ABC News Studios for Hulu. The show centers on the life of Brooklyn-based computer salesman John Ruffo, who admitted guilt to a $350 million bank fraud in 1998 and was due to start serving a 17-year federal prison sentence. Ruffo, however, disappeared without a trace on the day he was due to turn himself in.
A Wilderness of Error (2020)
 | A Wilderness of Error | |
| Genre True Crime | Seasons 161 minutes | |
| Director Marc Smerling | 6.5/10 | |
| Cast Errol Morris, Clay Boulware, John Morgan | ||
In 2020, director Marc Smerling helmed A Wilderness of Error, an American true crime documentary miniseries based on Errol Morris’ same-titled book. The series delves into the case of Army surgeon Jeffrey MacDonald, who faced charges for killing his pregnant wife and two young girls on February 17, 1970. He was found guilty of the crime on August 29, 1979, and has been incarcerated since 1982. Despite this, MacDonald maintains his innocence.
American Crime Story: The People Vs OJ (2016)
 | American Crime Story: The People Vs OJ | |
| Genre True Crime, Thriller | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Ryan Murphy | 8.4/10 | |
| Cast David R. Allen, John Berwick, Kyle Bridger | ||
The show is an anthology of true crimes that was developed by Ryan Murphy, Scott Alexander, and Larry Karaszewski. The Run of His Life: The People v. O. J. Simpson by Jeffrey Toobin served as the inspiration for the first season, which was titled The People v. O. J. Simpson. It comes after O. J. Simpson’s murder trial for the deaths of Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman.
The Murders at White House Farm (2020)
 | The Murders at White House Farm | |
| Genre True Crime | Seasons 1 | |
| Director Paul Whittington | 7.4/10 | |
| Cast Freddie Fox, Alexa Davies, Mark Addy | ||
The miniseries kicks off with the 1985 murders, with Jeremy Bamber (played by Freddie Fox) making a frantic call to the police, reporting that his sister Sheila (portrayed by Cressida Bonas) is wielding a rifle and posing a threat to the family. Upon their arrival, DCI Taff Jones (embodied by Stephen Graham) and DS Stan Jones (played by Mark Addy) initially conclude that it’s a case of murder-suicide. However, as the investigation unfolds, the real truth begins to emerge.
Summing it Up!
Now you know, what to watch to find the best true crime shows on Disney Plus. Surprisingly, it hosts a remarkable collection of riveting documentaries, heart-pounding dramas, and enthralling podcasts in this genre.
Here, you can dive deep into the twisted psyches of infamous serial killers and unravel the intricacies of real-life investigations, providing a captivating look into the shadowy realms of human behavior. While Disney+ might not be the conventional choice for true crime content, it offers a unique and captivating experience that’s sure to pique the interest of true crime aficionados.
